Joel,
I asked Hunter about this when the crank came in and he told me you were supposed to contact him with further information (like inside diameter measurements) about the bearing and/or bushing on the PTO side. He has not heard back from either you or your brother.
The reason he wanted this information is because there are marks on the PTO main journal that are suspect. (see attached picture
http://db.tt/KKP7z6t ) These marks make the PTO main Journal look AND FEEL like a rotary file and would eat into any bushing in a matter of seconds. This would create excessive clearance at the PTO main journal and that could very easily be the cause.
Excessive Ignition timing normally breaks rods first or screws up pistons like George said. However, if The main journal clearance was too much, then it could also contributed to the failure.
We have hundreds of these cranks in the field and this is the only failure that I have seen.
It is NOT a bad batch of material because we test every bar before we begin cutting...could you imagine the cost if we discovered a flaw AFTER processing an entire bar? These cranks each take several hours of machine time, and we don't like to waste machine time.
If you are looking to find a solution, we are willing to help you discover what happened, but you must supply us with the information we request. We do not volunteer information about what we suspect until we are satisfied with the information supplied to us. This is due to the fact that the information supplied often changes as we present ideas because the goal is too often to obtain a free replacement part and not so much to discover the problem.
Now Joel, please explain why, when you were questioned in this thread about whether or not you had heard from ARC you did not mention that you were supposed to get back with us with inside diameter measurements of the bushing? Not only did you fail to mention that, but you helped people get the impression that we were ignoring this. That is an unfair representation and it tells me a lot about how I should proceed.
To the armchair quarterbacks. I think I have earned a little more respect than to just immediately be vilified. Maybe next time get a little more information before slinging me up on the cross.
Moderators, you don't need to moderate this thread. I'll handle it.